By Cytonn Research Team, Oct 25, 2015
Treasury bill auctions were oversubscribed for the fourth straight week, with overall subscription rising to 336.0%, compared to 258.6% the previous week. The Central Bank of Kenya (CBK) took Kshs 33.5 bn this week compared to Kshs 12 bn offered, a clear indication that the government needs cash. The high subscription rates can be attributed to (i) investors locking in attractive yields in short-term government instruments, (ii) foreign investment flowing into the local debt markets as the returns are attractive, on a risk-adjusted basis. In the wake of comments by the CBK Governor, Dr. Patrick Njoroge, that the CBK will look to drive down interest rates in the near future, investors? preference was skewed towards the 364-day T-bill, which received the highest subscription rate of 516.0%, compared to 369.9% and 121.9% for the 91-day and 182-day, respectively. There was minimal increases in yields to 22.5%, 22.3% and 22.4%, from 22.1%, 21.8% and 21.8% for the 91-day, 182-day and 364-day papers, respectively. The minimal increases in yields, compared to just a few weeks ago where yields increased by over 300 basis points on a week to week basis indicates that the rate environment is slowly stabilizing.
The money market was relatively liquid in the week with the commercial banks? clearing account recording KSh 25.97 bn surplus from the 5.25% average Cash Reserve ratio. Due to the liquidity skewedness towards some banks, the interbank rate rose slightly to 13.8%, from 13.5% the previous week.
The shilling appreciated 0.9% against the dollar during the week, closing at 102.1 against the dollar, from 103.1 the previous week. We expect the shilling to continue strengthening in the short-term due to:
As highlighted in our Cytonn Report #41, the Government issued a 1-year amortized bond, with a weighted tenor of 9-months (273 days), to raise Kshs 20 bn for budgetary support. The bond received a 157.3% performance, and the yield was 22.9%, which was in line with our expectation of between 22.5% and 23.0%, which is the highest yielding treasury instrument. The Government further confirmed its preference for short-term borrowing by postponing the issuance of the Kshs 5 bn, 5-year infrastructure retail bond to avoid distorting the yield curve. The retail bond, named M-Akiba, was to be the first Government bond offered exclusively via mobile phone. As we highlighted on CNBC Africa (Cytonn Investments CNBC), in our view, this postponement was necessary and the effort may not have been too successful because:
As highlighted in our Cytonn Weekly #40, that Family Bank is set to issue its corporate bond of Kshs 10 bn, however the offering might be ill timed given the current interest rate environment and a market that is soured on the banking sector. In response to this, the bank reduced the size of their offering to Kshs 2 bn. The bond is being offered at a yield of 16.4% compared to 15.4% of a similar 5-year government bond, a risk premium of only 100 bps. In this environment, shrewd investors would demand at least a 300 bps premium to the government bond. However, we note that even the 15.4% 5 yr bond pricing base could also be distorted since there has been no recent trade on this and the government is reluctant to issue a 5-yr bond given pricing uncertainty. On a risk-adjusted basis and given both the interest rate and banking sector environment, the bank may struggle raising the funds.
We have a seen a number of downgrades to the Kenyan economy due to the harsh economic environment. The IMF and World Bank, reduced their forecasts to 6.0% and 5.4%, respectively from the close to 7% rate at the beginning of the year. S&P also downgraded their credit outlook for Kenya from stable to negative, maintaining the credit rating at B+. Cytonn?s GDP forecast for 2015 is at between 4.7% - 4.9%, is below both IMF and World Bank, as a result of the poor-operating environment and the increased debt burden by the government. Despite this challenging macroeconomic environment, inflation rates, which have remained relatively low for the better part of the year, are expected to inch upwards but to remain within the CBK?s target. We expect inflation for the month of October to continue with the recent upward trend to 6.0% - 6.2%, from last month?s 5.97%, owing to increased prices in non-food and non-fuel items. Despite all the above Kenya is still a good long-term investment destination since major actions are being undertaken to stabilise the economy, and most recently we have seen the currency strengthen and the CBK governor come up strongly indicating that they shall help reduce the interest rates.
The Government?s borrowing programme for the current fiscal year, targeted at Kshs. 219 bn, has been stepped up, having borrowed Kshs 52 bn for the current fiscal year. Given that the Government has resorted to funding the budget through short-term borrowings, which mature within the current fiscal year, we expect the aggressive borrowing to continue, as pressure remains to re-finance their obligations but we think that the rates should be capping at the current levels given the high levels of subscriptions witnessed recently. We maintain our view that investors should be biased towards short-term fixed income instruments, given the uncertainty in the interest rate environment.
During the week the market was on a positive trend with NSE 20, NASI and NSE 25 gaining 1.3%, 1.9% and 2.2%, respectively, on the back of gains in Britam, EABL and Safaricom which gained 11.3%, 6.7% and 2.8%, respectively. Foreign investor?s participation remained high during the week at 82.6%, about the same level of 82.4% the previous week with the foreign investors being net buyers. Since the February peak, NASI and NSE 20 have been down 21.4%, and 28.1%, firmly in correction territory, and down 14.3% and 22.7% on an YTD basis, respectively.
Britam and Acorn settled their civil suits; Cytonn was also party to the suits but the suits against Cytonn and / or its directors were withdrawn since Cytonn has no interest in the matter. The settlement resulted in Britam getting the majority of the Kshs. 5 billion of real estate development. It is notable that while the developments were initiated by Britam?s Asset Management division, BAAM, together with Acorn, for the benefit of BAAM clients, the real estate developments will now go to Britam shareholders. Consequently, while the settlement is positive for Britam shareholders, it effectively short changes BAAM clients by denying them access to real estate returns. This calls into question the regulatory ability to protect the interest of the investing public given that the deals against the investing public to the benefit of shareholders have been done in plain view of the regulator. We cannot achieve the aspiration of Nairobi as a regional financial services centre without a strong culture of protecting the interests of the investing public.
The Insurance Regulatory Authority released the Q2?2015 Industry Report, which indicated that the industry?s net premiums grew by 15.3% to Kshs. 88.4 bn in Q2?2015, from Kshs. 76.6 bn in Q2?2014. Life Insurance recorded higher growth than General Insurance at 15.7% and 14.6%, respectively, however the industry is driven by the general insurance business, which accounted for 66.4% of the entire premiums. Reinsurers recorded a 30.4% growth in premiums from Kshs. 7.1 bn in Q2?2014 to Kshs. 9.3 bn in Q2?2015, with general insurance business ceding most premiums contributing to 87.0% of the total premiums. Insurance claims grew by 16.4% from Kshs. 33.6 bn in Q2?2014 to Kshs. 39.2 bn in Q2?2015, with general business having most claims at 62.3%, compared to life business at 37.7%. The total industry assets grew by 16.1% from Kshs. 392.2 bn in Q2?2014 to Kshs. 455.5 as at Q2?2015. Kenya?s insurance industry has high growth prospects due to (i) potential high premium growth rate since the market is too concentrated, (ii) an increasing asset base, and (iii) a low penetration rate standing at 2.9% of GDP. However, the growth in claims outpacing growth in premiums is worrying, and could be an indicator that premium growth is being driven by business of questionable quality. We are currently analysing listed insurance companies and shall be releasing our comprehensive insurance report on the 2nd of November 2015.
Jubilee Insurance Holdings has announced its partnership with Congolese Insurance Company ?Société Nationale des Assurance? (?SONAS?), to offer medical and life cover products, pending approval on their request to set up shop in the Central African Nation. This comes in the wake of DRC having amended their insurance law which now allows the entry of foreign insurance companies. Under the new law, foreign insurance companies are required to have a minimum capital base of USD 10 mn (about Kshs. 1 bn) to operate in the country. The new Insurance Code represents a revolution in the sector, which has in the past been affected by the disparity of laws, which subsequently locked out the participation of both foreign and local companies to venture and compete successfully in the country, through the monopoly granted to SONAS. Over the years, there has been a lack of competition in the insurance industry in the country since SONAS was the only company offering insurance therefore subjecting the public to expensive insurance products. By introducing this new policy: (i) It puts an end to the monopoly granted to SONAS, (ii) liberalizes the sector, and (iii) establishes an insurance regulatory authority in DR Congo whose entry into force will be in March 2016. These are positive changes for the insurance market, especially policy holders given increased competition and better regulation.
TransCentury, a Kenyan investment firm, has announced plans to raise funds through a cash call from its shareholders for the purpose of (i) paying off its Kshs. 5.9 bn convertible bond due in March 2016 and (ii) to support its construction and energy business after the Board announced a new growth strategy. The bondholders had been given up until late September to exercise their conversion rights but due to the low share price it is highly unlikely that they considered this avenue. The conversion price as per the bond guidelines is at Kshs. 49.6 per share, so it would be cheaper to buy the stock at the current price of Kshs. 14.0. The company initially borrowed Kshs. 5.9 bn (USD 60 mn) in 2011 and so far close to Kshs. 410.0 mn (USD 4.0 mn) has been converted. With the likelihood that the bondholders did not convert the debt, it is no surprise that TransCentury is looking to their shareholders for more capital.
Next week sees the commencement of Q3?2015 earnings releases for the banking sector in Kenya. With the challenging operating environment, characterised by high interest rates, which saw banks revise upwards the interest rates on loans, we expect slow earnings growth compared to Q3?2015, as a result of:
Though the current interest rate environment is expected to result to higher Non-performing Loans (NPL?s), we expect the impact to be minimal as banks extend the duration of the loan, rather than increase monthly payments, in order to protect borrowers and maintain the quality of their loan book.
We estimate that Equity Bank will report earnings per share of Kshs. 3.53, a 16.5% increment from last year.
We remain neutral with a bias to negative on equities given the significantly lower earnings growth prospects for this year. The market is now purely a stock pickers? market, with few pockets of value.
All prices in Kshs unless stated |
|||||||||
EQUITY RECOMMENDATIONS - WEEK ENDED 23/10/2015 |
|||||||||
No. |
Company |
Price as at 16/10/15 |
Price as at 23/10/15 |
w/w Change |
Target Price |
Dividend Yield |
Upside/ (Downside) |
Recommendation |
|
1. |
KCB |
41.75 |
41.75 |
0.0% |
58.4 |
6.4% |
46.3% |
Buy |
|
2. |
Standard Chartered |
204.00 |
201.00 |
(1.5%) |
273.8 |
8.1% |
44.3% |
Buy |
|
3. |
NIC |
39.00 |
38.00 |
(2.6%) |
50.0 |
2.9% |
34.4% |
Buy |
|
4. |
Equity |
41.00 |
41.00 |
0.0% |
52.5 |
5.3% |
33.5% |
Buy |
|
5. |
Uchumi |
9.45 |
9.40 |
(0.5%) |
11.2 |
0.0% |
19.6% |
Accumulate |
|
6. |
Co-operative |
16.60 |
17.00 |
2.4% |
19.6 |
3.6% |
19.1% |
Accumulate |
|
7. |
Barclays |
11.90 |
12.60 |
5.9% |
14.0 |
8.0% |
19.0% |
Accumulate |
|
8. |
DTBK |
191.00 |
192.00 |
0.5% |
217.2 |
1.4% |
14.5% |
Accumulate |
|
9. |
Housing Finance |
20.75 |
20.75 |
0.0% |
21.2 |
5.9% |
8.3% |
Hold |
|
10. |
I&M |
100.00 |
101.00 |
1.0% |
101.2 |
2.7% |
2.9% |
Lighten |
|
11. |
CfC Stanbic |
89.50 |
89.00 |
(0.6%) |
75.4 |
0.0% |
(15.3%) |
Sell |
|
12. |
National Bank |
16.10 |
14.95 |
(7.1%) |
6.5 |
0.0% |
(56.7%) |
Sell |
|
*Target Price as per Cytonn Analyst estimates |
Note that this past week we were buyers of both KCB and Equity Bank for our investment portfolios and we suggest investors look to buying banking stocks for long-term.
Catalyst Principal Partners have increased their shareholding in Jamii Bora Bank to 11%. Catalyst Principal Partners first invested in Jamii Bora in 2014 when it acquired an undisclosed stake for an undisclosed amount. Catalyst Fund 1 is a USD125 million Eastern Africa focused private equity fund that invests in emerging and mid-sized companies with strong growth and profitability prospects, and strong alignment with experienced management teams. The fund focuses on the following sectors (i) consumer goods and retail, (ii) financial and business services, (iii) industrials, manufacturing and value-add processing, (iv) technology & telecommunications, and (v) healthcare & education services. The East Africa financial services industry has continued to remain attractive to private equity players. International Finance Corporation and CDC Group plc recently invested USD 24 million to acquire a 5% holding in Tanzania?s CRDB Bank, valuing the bank at USD 480 million and a PBV multiple of 2.3x.
We reiterate our bullish stance on PE as an asset class, particularly in financial services, driven by:
The Nairobi Securities Exchange became the 4th African bourse (behind South Africa, Nigeria and Ghana) to launch a Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT) market, in what coincided with the opening of the Stanlib Fahari I-REIT public offer. The Stanlib Fahari I-REIT public offer, to be issued at a minimum subscription of Kshs 20,000 (1,000 units) and a nominal value of Kshs 20 each will close on November 12th. This offer is to an unrestricted initial public offer, hence the waiver not to be issued solely to professional investors, where the minimum issue price should be at least Kshs 5 mn. The offer will then go through an allotment process, with a subsequent listing of units on the NSE. Stanlib Fahari I-REIT is expected to target properties with attractive rental income and capital gains, giving investors exposure to a reliable and growing return profile in the long-term.
This is a very positive and historic step by both Stanlib and the regulator and if well executed, should both deepen our capital markets and give access to retail investors seeking real estate exposure.
The US has the world?s most advanced REIT market in the world. In Africa, growth in this market has been limited by the absence of enabling legislation. South Africa has traded in REITs for the last 10 years, while Ghana has had access to REITs since 1994 and Nigeria since 2007. Like any other listed security, its future value will be determined by market dynamics. REITs are expected to create liquidity, meaning unit-holders can sell their holdings or buy more.
We applaud the I-REIT offering by Stanlib for various reasons:
However, issues remain which need to be addressed:
According to Global Cities: The 2016 Report, Nairobi has been placed on the list as one of the 5 cities to watch based on the booming retail sector in the country. The report indicates that around 1.8 million sq. ft. of modern shopping mall space has opened in 2015. Given that the mall stock initially totalled 980,000 sq. ft., this amounts to a revolution in the city?s retail experience, which matches the huge economic and demographic changes that have unfolded in Kenya. However, we would now be cautious on additional mall investments given the amount of space coming into the market.
Interest rates on Government securities in Kenya have been on a steep upward trend and we have also seen the high rates passed on to bank customers. In a report by Business Daily this week, some customers have had as high as 12% revision in their bank rates and some being charged high rates of up to 27%.
After covering the impacts of a high interest rates environment on the Kenyan economy, and the corresponding impact on investments in our Cytonn Weekly Report #38; this week we turn our attention to the key factors that determine the direction of interest rates in an economy, and which of these factors resulted into the high interest rates environment we presently have in Kenya, and finally we address what we need to do in terms of policy action to contain the volatile interest rates environment.
Interest rates in an economy are determined by the below factors:
Interest rates environment in Kenya have witnessed volatility over the last calendar year, with a sharp increase in rates being the normal trend. This can be evidenced by the 91-day Treasury bill rising from a rate of 8.6% in December 2014, to 22.5% in last week?s auction. In tandem with this, the Central Bank lending rates have also increased by 300 basis points to stand at 11.5%. This high interest rates environment was as a result of;
Of key to note is that despite the above factors contributing to high interest rates environment in Kenya, inflation rates have remained relatively low, within the CBK?s target of 2.5% - 7.5%, standing at 5.9% as for the month of September 2015.
So, looking at the above, inflation is not the issue since it is within target, monetary policy / CBK is not the issue since the core mandate of price stability is under control; the key issues are fiscal policy, which points to treasury and economic management of public finances by the executive.
Consequently, a number of key policy issues need to be addressed in order to contain the current interest rates environment:
To address the country's rate challenges, we need to be candid about the key issues. A comprehensive and objective analysis points to a need to enhance executive management of public finances before the rate environment causes irreparable damage to our economy.
--------------------------
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this publication, are those of the writers where particulars are not warranted- as the facts may change from time to time. This publication is meant for general information only, and is not a warranty, representation or solicitation for any product that may be on offer. Readers are thereby advised in all circumstances, to seek the advice of an independent financial advisor to advise them of the suitability of any financial product for their investment purposes.