By Research Team, Nov 3, 2019
During the month of October, T-bill auctions recorded an undersubscription, with the overall rate coming in at 84.5%, compared to 105.4% recorded in the month of September 2019. The subscription rates for the 91-day came in at 122.0%, which was lower than the 128.6% recorded in September. The subscription rates for the 182-day and 364-day came in at 27.1% and 195.5%, higher than the 23.5% and 127.3%, recorded in September, respectively. The yields on the 91-day paper increased by 0.1% points to 6.4%, from 6.3%, while the yield on the 182-day paper and 364-day paper remained stable at 7.2% and 9.8%, respectively in October. The y/y inflation for the month of October increased to 4.95%, from 3.8% recorded in September mainly due to a 0.5% increase in the food and non-alcoholic drinks’ index, due to an increase in prices of significant food items including maize grain-loose, maize flour-sifted and tomatoes, which increased by 5.8%, 4.6% and 4.4%, respectively. During the week, World Bank Group released the Kenya Economic Update October 2019. According to the report, the country’s total debt stock rose by 16.0% to Kshs 5.8 tn in June 2019, from Kshs 5.0 tn in the year to June 2018, with the domestic debt accounting for 48.0% of the total debt (Kshs 2.8 tn) while foreign debt amounted to 52.0% (Kshs 3.0 tn);
During the month of October, the equities market was on an upward trend, with NASI, NSE 20, and NSE 25 increasing by 9.7%, 8.8%, and 13.0%, respectively. The increase recorded in NASI was driven by gains in large-cap bank stocks such as NCBA Group, Equity Group, and KCB Group, which gained by 30.7%, 24.2%, and 23.2%, respectively, owing to expectations of the repeal of the interest rate cap. During the week, the Capital Markets Authority released the Capital Markets Soundness Report (CMSR) for Q3’ 2019. This report analyses the Kenyan Capital Markets industry focusing on the various policy issues, which may be a promoter or threat to its growth. For the equities section they discuss elements such as NSE 20 and NASI indexes volatility, turnover ratio, foreign investor turnover, net foreign portfolio flow, and market concentration. During the month, President Uhuru Kenyatta submitted a memorandum to the Speaker of the National Assembly detailing his refusal to assent to the Finance Bill 2019, and recommending a repeal of the interest rate cap;
During the month, various real estate industry reports were released, namely the Hass Property Sales and Land Index Q3’2019 Reports, the World Bank’s Doing Business Report 2020, and the JLL Spotlight on Africa Q4’2019 Report. In the residential sector, various projects were launched including affordable housing projects for Nyeri County and Nairobi’s Eastlands Regeneration. In the commercial office sector, Kofisi, a co-working spaces provider opened up in Karen, while two local pension schemes announced plans to purchase commercial properties for investment purposes. In the retail sector, various retailers announced expansion plans including Naivas, Java, and Artcaffe, while Botswana-based retailer, Choppies, announced possible plans of exiting the market. In the hospitality scene, South African-based hotel group, City Lodge, launched its final phase of the Two Rivers-based City Lodge Hotel, as various Kenyan Hotels also bagged seven awards at the World Luxury Hotel Awards 2019, in Finland. Finally, in the infrastructure sector, the President of Kenya, H.E Uhuru Kenyatta, launched two major projects in Nairobi, namely the construction of the Jomo Kenyatta International Airport – James Gichuru Express Highway, and the operationalization of the Standard Gauge Railway Phase 2, which connects Nairobi to Naivasha.
Money Markets, T-Bills & T-Bonds Primary Auction:
During the month of October, T-bill auctions recorded an undersubscription, with the overall rate coming in at 84.5%, compared to 105.4% recorded in the month of September 2019. The subscription rates for the 91-day came in at 122.0%, which was lower than the 128.6% recorded in September. The subscription rates for the 182-day and 364-day came in at 27.1% and 195.5%, higher than the 23.5% and 127.3%, recorded in September, respectively. The yields on the 91-day increased by 0.1% points to 6.4%, from 6.3%, while the yield on the 182-day paper and 364-day paper, recorded no change in the yields remaining stable at 7.2% and 9.8%, respectively in October. The T-bills acceptance rate came in at 71.4% during the month, compared to 67.9% recorded in September, with the government accepting a total of Kshs 57.9 bn of the Kshs 81.1 bn worth of bids received.
The Central Bank remained disciplined in rejecting expensive bids in order to ensure the stability of interest rates.
During the week, T-bills were oversubscribed, with the subscription rate coming in at 114.3%, up from 72.8% the previous week. The oversubscription is partly attributable to favourable liquidity in the money market during the week. The yield on the 91-day, 182-day, and 364-day papers remained unchanged at 6.4%, 7.2% and 9.8%. The acceptance rate dropped to 86.5% from 94.3%, recorded the previous week, with the government accepting Kshs 23.7 bn of the Kshs 27.4 bn bids received.
The 91-day T-bill is currently trading at a yield of 6.4%, which is below its 5-year average of 8.6%. The lower yield on the 91-day paper is mainly attributable to the low-interest rate environment that has persisted since the passing of the law capping interest rates.
For the month of October, the National Treasury issued a tax-exempt 16-year Kshs 60.0 bn infrastructure bond (IFB1/2019/16) with market-determined coupon rates for the purpose of financing the infrastructure projects in the FY 2019/20 budget estimates. The bond was oversubscribed as per our expectations due to its tax-free incentive that translates to higher returns, receiving bids totaling Kshs 86.9 bn of the Kshs 60.0 bn on offer, translating to a subscription rate of 144.9%. The weighted average rate of accepted bids was at 12.4% in line with our expectations of 12.3% - 12.5%.
In the money markets, 3-month bank placements ended the week at 8.5% (based on what we have been offered by various banks), the 91-day T-bill came in at 6.4%, while the average of Top 5 Money Market Funds came in at 10.2%, which was a 0.1% increase from 10.1% recorded in the previous week. The Cytonn Money Market Fund closed the week at 11.0%, from 10.9% recorded the previous week.
Secondary Bond Market:
The yields on government securities in the secondary market remained relatively stable during the month of October, as the Central Bank of Kenya continued to reject expensive bids in the primary market. On a YTD basis, government securities on the secondary market have gained with yields declining across the board, which has, in turn, led to price appreciation.
Liquidity:
Liquidity in the money markets remained favourable during the month of October despite the average interbank rate rising to 7.0%, from 6.5% recorded in September, supported by Government open market activities, which offset tax payments. During the week, the average interbank rate dropped to 6.4% from 6.9% recorded the previous week, pointing to increasing liquidity in the money markets. The average interbank volumes rose by 33.5% to Kshs 17.4 bn, from Kshs 13.1 bn recorded the previous week.
Kenya Eurobonds:
According to Reuters, the yield on the 10-year Eurobond issued in June 2014 decreased by 0.2% points to 5.4% in October, from 5.6% in September 2019. During the week, the yield on the 10-year Eurobond remained stable at 5.4% similar to the previous week.
During the month, the yields on the 10-year and 30-year Eurobond issued in February 2018 both declined by 0.3% points to close at 6.4% from 6.7% in September and at 7.8% from 8.1% in September, respectively. During the week, the yield on the 10-year and 30-year Eurobond remained unchanged at 6.4 and 7.8%, respectively.
During the month, the yields on the newly issued dual-tranche Eurobond with 7-years declined by 0.2% points to 6.2% from 6.4% in September 2019. The 12-year Eurobond also declined by 0.2% points to 7.2% from 7.4% recorded in September 2019. During the week, the yields on the 7-year Eurobond declined by 0.2% points to 6.1% from 6.3% the previous week, while the 12-year Eurobond remained unchanged at 7.2%.
Kenya Shilling:
The Kenya Shilling appreciated by 0.7% against the US Dollar during the month of October to Kshs 103.2 from Kshs 103.9 at the end of September, supported by inflows from diaspora remittances and portfolio investors buying government debt. During the week, the Kenya Shilling remained stable against the US Dollar to close at Kshs 103.3, which was similar to the value recorded in the previous week. On a YTD basis, the shilling has depreciated by 1.4% against the US Dollar, in comparison to the 1.3% appreciation in 2018. In our view, the shilling should remain relatively stable against the dollar in the short term, supported by:
Inflation:
Major Inflation Changes in the Month of October 2019 |
|||
Broad Commodity Group |
Price change m/m (October-19/August-19) |
Price change y/y (October-19/October-18) |
Reason |
Food & Non-Alcoholic Beverages |
0.5% |
8.7% |
The m/m increase was due to an increase in prices of commodities such as maize flour- sifted and tomatoes |
Transport Cost |
(0.3%) |
2.5% |
The m/m decline was mainly on account of the reduction in pump prices of diesel and petrol by 1.0% and 4.2%, respectively. |
Housing, Water, Electricity, Gas and other Fuels |
0.1% |
0.9% |
The m/m increase was mainly as a result of an increase in prices of some cooking fuels following the 0.4% increase in kerosene prices |
Overall Inflation |
0.3% |
4.95% |
The m/m increase was due to a 0.5% increase in the food index which has a CPI weight of 36.0% |
The y/y inflation for the month of October increased to 4.95%, from 3.8% recorded in September, which exceeded our projections of an increase to 4.4%-4.8%. Month-on-month inflation also increased by 0.3%, which was attributable to:
Monthly Highlight:
During the week, World Bank Group released the Kenya Economic Update October 2019. Below are the key take-outs from the report:
Below is a table showing average projected GDP growth for Kenya in 2019 with an upward readjustment of the World Bank; noteworthy being that the highest projection is by the Central Bank of Kenya at 6.3%. We shall be updating this table should projections change and shall highlight who had the most accurate projection at the end of the year.
Kenya 2019 Annual GDP Growth Outlook |
|||||
No. |
Organization |
Q1'2019 |
Q2'2019 |
Q3’2019 |
Q4’2019 |
1. |
Central Bank of Kenya |
6.3% |
6.3% |
6.3% |
6.3% |
2. |
Euromonitor International |
5.9% |
5.9% |
6.3% |
6.3% |
3. |
Citigroup Global Markets |
6.1% |
6.1% |
6.1% |
6.1% |
4. |
PNB Paribas |
6.0% |
6.0% |
6.1% |
6.1% |
5. |
The National Treasury |
6.2% |
6.2% |
6.0% |
6.0% |
6. |
African Development Bank (AfDB) |
6.0% |
6.0% |
6.0% |
6.0% |
7. |
UK HSBC |
6.0% |
6.0% |
6.0% |
6.0% |
8. |
Cytonn Investments Management Plc |
5.8% |
5.8% |
5.8% |
5.8% |
9. |
World Bank* |
5.8% |
5.7% |
5.7% |
5.8% |
10. |
Euler Hermes |
5.7% |
5.7% |
5.7% |
5.7% |
11. |
International Monetary Fund (IMF) |
6.1% |
5.8% |
5.6% |
5.6% |
12. |
Focus Economics |
5.8% |
5.8% |
5.6% |
5.6% |
13. |
JPMorgan |
5.7% |
5.7% |
5.6% |
5.6% |
14. |
Oxford Economics |
5.6% |
5.6% |
5.6% |
5.6% |
|
Average |
5.9% |
5.9% |
5.9% |
5.9% |
*Revised Growth rates for Q4’2019
In conclusion, the macroeconomic environment in Kenya remains stable with low inflation and a manageable current account deficit. However, interest rate caps have reduced the effectiveness of the monetary policy transmission and constrained the operating environment for the banking sector. If the interest rate cap is removed, the potency of the monetary policy will be restored. Despite a reduction in the fiscal deficit from 9.1% of GDP in FY 2016/17 to 7.4% of GDP in FY 2017/18, the fiscal deficit expanded to 7.7% in FY 2018/19 compared to a target deficit of 6.8% of GDP. The fiscal deficit at 0.9% points above the target is due to revenue shortfalls and expenditure pressures.
Rates in the fixed income market have remained relatively stable as the government rejects expensive bids. Despite the rise in net revenue collections in Q1’2019 by 13.1% to Kshs 372.3 bn from Kshs 329.2 bn recorded in a similar period last year, we still don’t expect the government to meet the Kshs 2.1 tn revenue target for FY’2019/2020, creating uncertainty in the interest rate environment as additional borrowing from the domestic market goes to plug the deficit. Putting into consideration the possible repeal of the interest rate cap, we expect improved private sector credit growth in the country, especially access to credit by MSMEs. This will lead to increased competition for bank funds from both the private and public sectors, thereby reducing liquidity in the money market, resulting in upward pressure on interest rates. Owing to this, we will be updating our Fixed Income House View.
Markets Performance
During the month of October, the equities market was on an upward trend, with NASI, NSE 20, and NSE 25 increasing by 9.7%, 8.8%, and 13.0%, respectively. The increase recorded in NASI was driven by gains in large-cap bank stocks such as NCBA Group, Equity Group, KCB Group and Co-operative Bank, which recorded gains of 30.7%, 24.2%, 23.2% and 22.3%, respectively, owing to expectations of the repeal of the interest rate cap. For this week, the market was on an upward trend, with NASI, NSE 20, and NSE 25 increasing by 9.5 %, 9.8%, and 13.2%, respectively, taking their YTD performance to gains/(losses) of 17.0%, (3.5%) and 14.9%, respectively. The improvement in NASI was largely due to gains recorded in large-cap counters such as Co-operative Bank, KCB Group, and NCBA, which recorded gains of 26.4% and 20.8%, and 17.4%, respectively.
Equities turnover increased by 55.3% during the month to USD 157.8 mn, from USD 101.6 mn in September 2019. Foreign investors became net sellers for the month, with a net selling position of USD 14.8 mn, compared to September’s net buying position of USD 6.6 mn. For this week, equities turnover increased by 82.2% to USD 71.1 mn, from USD 39.0 mn the previous week, bringing the year to date (YTD) turnover to USD 1,242.1 mn. Foreign investors remained net sellers for the week, with a net selling position of USD 4.7 mn, a 65.6% increase from last week’s net selling position of USD 2.8 mn.
The market is currently trading at a price to earnings ratio (P/E) of 12.2x, 8.3% below the historical average of 13.3x, and a dividend yield of 6.4%, above the historical average of 3.9%. With the market trading at valuations below the historical average, we believe there is value in the market. The current P/E valuation of 12.2x is 25.9% above the most recent trough valuation of 9.7x experienced in the first week of February 2017, and 47.1% above the previous trough valuation of 8.3x experienced in December 2011. The charts below indicate the historical P/E and dividend yields of the market.
Monthly Highlights
During the week, Capital Markets Authority (CMA) released the Capital Markets Soundness Report (CMSR) for Q3’ 2019. This report analyses the Kenyan Capital Markets industry focusing on the various policy issues that may be a promoter or threat to its growth. For the equities section, they discuss elements such as NSE 20 and NASI indexes volatility, turnover ratio, foreign investor turnover, net foreign portfolio flow, and market concentration. These components were used to assess the equity market depth in Kenya.
In our view, efforts by the government and the CMA to improve the soundness of the capital markets will improve market depth, access to foreign exchange, market transparency and capacity of local investors as assessed in the Absa 2019 Africa Financial Markets Index .
During the month, President Uhuru Kenyatta submitted a memorandum to the Speaker of the National Assembly detailing his refusal to assent to the Finance Bill 2019. The President, instead, recommended a repeal of the interest rate cap. In the memorandum, the President cited that while the purpose of the capping was to address the wide concerns about affordability and availability of credit to Kenyans, the capping of interest rates instead caused unintended consequences that are significant and damaging to the economy and Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs). In the memo, the president highlighted that the re-introduction of Clause 45 of the Bill by the National Assembly would worsen the unintended effects brought about by the cap such as;
For a more detailed analysis, please see Cytonn Weekly #42/2019
Universe of Coverage
Banks |
Price at 30/9/2019 |
Price at 31/10/2019 |
Price at 25/10/2019 |
Price at 1/11/2019 |
m/m change |
w/w change |
Target Price |
Upside/ Downside |
P/TBv Multiple |
Recommendation |
Sanlam |
18.8 |
17.2 |
17.1 |
16.0 |
(8.5%) |
(6.2%) |
29.0 |
81.3% |
0.8x |
Buy |
I&M Holdings |
45.0 |
50.5 |
45.2 |
47.0 |
12.2% |
4.1% |
79.8 |
77.5% |
0.8x |
Buy |
Diamond Trust Bank |
114 |
117.75 |
115.0 |
116.0 |
3.3% |
0.9% |
175.6 |
53.7% |
0.6x |
Buy |
Britam |
7.1 |
7.0 |
6.9 |
7.0 |
(0.8%) |
1.2% |
8.8 |
30.7% |
0.7x |
Buy |
CIC Group |
3.1 |
3.0 |
3.0 |
3.0 |
(1.0%) |
2.4% |
3.8 |
29.2% |
1.2x |
Buy |
KCB Group |
42.0 |
51.8 |
44.1 |
53.3 |
23.2% |
20.7% |
61.4 |
23.6% |
1.4x |
Buy |
Kenya Reinsurance |
2.9 |
3.2 |
3.0 |
3.2 |
9.7% |
4.6% |
3.8 |
23.5% |
0.1x |
Buy |
Liberty Holdings |
9.7 |
9.7 |
10.4 |
9.7 |
(0.2%) |
(6.7%) |
11.3 |
21.6% |
0.7x |
Buy |
Equity Group |
37.5 |
46.5 |
40.0 |
46.5 |
24.2% |
16.4% |
53.0 |
19.3% |
1.9x |
Accumulate |
Jubilee holdings |
350.0 |
336.0 |
350.0 |
360.0 |
(4.0%) |
2.9% |
418.5 |
18.8% |
1.0x |
Accumulate |
Co-operative Bank |
11.9 |
14.6 |
12.5 |
15.8 |
22.3% |
26.4% |
15.0 |
3.3% |
1.4x |
Lighten |
Barclays Bank |
11.0 |
13.3 |
11.5 |
13.5 |
21.5% |
17.4% |
12.6 |
3.2% |
1.8x |
Lighten |
Standard Chartered |
199.8 |
205.3 |
198.5 |
214.8 |
2.8% |
8.2% |
208.0 |
3.1% |
1.7x |
Lighten |
NCBA Group |
30.0 |
39.2 |
33.6 |
39.5 |
30.7% |
17.4% |
37.9 |
(0.6%) |
0.8x |
Sell |
Stanbic Holdings |
96.0 |
106.5 |
101.8 |
110.5 |
10.9% |
8.6% |
100.5 |
(2.9%) |
1.2x |
Sell |
HF Group |
7.0 |
6.6 |
6.7 |
7.2 |
(6.0%) |
7.8% |
2.8 |
(61.7%) |
0.3x |
Sell |
*Target Price as per Cytonn Analyst estimates **Upside / (Downside) is adjusted for Dividend Yield ***Banks in which Cytonn and/or its affiliates are invested in |
We are “Positive” on equities for investors as the sustained price declines has seen the market P/E decline to below its historical average. We expect increased market activity, and possibly increased inflows from foreign investors, as they take advantage of the attractive valuations, to support the positive performance.
I. Industry Reports
During the month, Hass Consult, a local real estate agency, released the Hass Property Sales and Rental Index Q3’2019. As per the report, the residential sector continues to be influenced by weak private sector credit growth, which has constrained access to financing for homebuyers and developers alike. Overall, the market recorded a q/q price growth of 0.9% and an annual depreciation of 3.4%, with semi-detached houses leading the market with an annual price growth of 6.0% and a q/q growth of 3.4%. Other key take-outs were:
The report is in tandem with the Cytonn Q3’2019 Markets Review, according to which, while prices depreciated across the market by 0.2% with the tough economic environment exerting pressure on the prices and market uptake, rental yields notably improved across the residential market with apartments recording average rental yields of 5.2%, in comparison to 4.9% in H1’2019, whereas detached markets recorded an average of 4.6%, in comparison to 3.9% in H1’2019, largely attributable to increase in occupancy rates as homebuyers took advantage of the pricing discounts as demand for affordability continue to aggravate. We expect appetite for the rental market to continue growing, especially in the high-end and upper mid-end markets. The growing appetite for affordable homes should stimulate uptake in the lower mid-end markets in areas such as Athi River, Thindigua and Ruaka as they continue to exhibit high demand from end buyers, due to their proximity to commercial nodes such as the CBD, Westlands, and Upperhill.
The firm also released the Hass Land Index Q3’2019. According to the report, land prices over the quarter rose marginally amidst anticipations of the repeal of the interest rate cap, which is expected to see increased lending to the private sector, thus stimulating the general economy. The key take-outs from the land report were as follows:
This is in line with our Cytonn Q3’2019 Markets Review, according to which land in satellite areas recorded the highest annual appreciation at 6.1%, in comparison to Nairobi suburbs’ average of 0.8%. We expect the continued focus on affordable housing to boost land prices in Satellite Towns such as Ruiru, Ruaka and Utawala supported by the ongoing infrastructural improvements.
Other reports released during the month included:
II. Residential Sector
Amidst the affordability concerns in Kenya, we expect the affordable housing sector to continue shaping up, attracting local and international investments. We also expect the overall residential market to improve especially on the back of anticipated growth of private sector lending once the interest rate cap is repealed.
III. Commercial Office Sector
We expect to see a slowdown in commercial office space building activity, with the current stock being converted to modern concepts such as co-working spaces in a bid to attract tenancy and institutional buyers as concepts such as serviced offices attract relatively high rental yields of up to 13.4% in comparison to mainstream offices which generate average rental yields of 8.0%.
IV. Retail Sector
We expect the retail sector to remain vibrant on the back of a growing middle class and increased retailer expansion, which means more space uptake for developers.
V. Hospitality Sector
We expect the hospitality sector’s performance to remain on an upward trajectory supported by increased interest from international investors, and a vibrant tourism sector.
VI. Infrastructure Sector
With the Government’s Kenya economic transformation agenda, we expect to see more infrastructural projects being unveiled, which in turn will boost the real estate sector’s performance and also lead to opening up of more areas for real estate development.
VII. Listed Real Estate
During the month, the Fahari I-REIT closed the month at Kshs 8.8, a 13.2% increase from the month’s opening price of Kshs 7.8. On average, during the month, the I-REIT traded at an average of Kshs 8.4, 5.9% lower than its YTD average of Kshs 8.9. The I-REIT’s performance and continued drop in its value is as a result of poor market perception and thus, low investor appetite.
We anticipate an improvement in the real estate sector on the back of (i) steady economic growth, with the World Bank projecting a 6.0% GDP growth in 2020, (ii) continued infrastructural improvements, and (iii) stable economy and private sector credit growth once the interest cap law is repealed.
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this publication are those of the writers where particulars are not warranted. This publication is meant for general information only and is not a warranty, representation, advice or solicitation of any nature. Readers are advised in all circumstances to seek the advice of a registered investment advisor.